"/>
Spotlight: India debates over holding simultaneous polls for Union, states
Source: Xinhua   2018-02-04 18:00:10

by Pankaj Yadav

NEW DELHI, Feb. 4 (Xinhua) -- Debate has started in Indian political circles as the country goes to the general elections in 2019.

Three days prior to flying to Davos on Jan. 22 to participate in the World Economic Forum, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi in a TV interview strongly advocated the idea of holding simultaneous elections at the Centre and in all the states.

This, he said, will save a lot of money and also let the politicians focus on works for full five years without being disturbed by elections, which have lately become a round-the-year event in India.

On an average, as many as five Indian states go to polls every year. Whenever the states go to polls, it becomes a slugfest between the ruling and the opposition parties. As all resources are diverted to the polls, governance and development works take a back seat during such times.

For the first 20 years since India gained Independence in 1947, elections were held simultaneously for the parliament and all state legislatures. This was so because the polls held in that era gave a decisive verdict to the then ruling party.

The first four simultaneous elections for Centre and states were held in 1951, 1957, 1962 and 1967. But slowly that trend disappeared and frequent mid-term polls were witnessed.

This trend of holding elections at different times for different states, and the Centre, has been there for almost five decades now. More so since the late 1990s, an era which saw many government changes at the Centre and multiple parliamentary elections held over a span of four years. The government headed by former premier Atal Bihari Vajpayee in 1996 lasted only for 13 days.

Hence comes forth this proposal of holding simultaneous elections in both states and at the Centre. The idea gained significance especially after reiteration by Modi on Jan. 19. Though there are valid arguments cited against the idea too.

Supporting the idea per se, Dr Jaswant Singh, a political analyst in Delhi, said that it's a good idea if implemented.

"Just like in the United States and in other countries where federal and provincial elections are held simultaneously, we can also think of adopting the idea," he said.

Toeing the prime minister's line, senior leader of the country's main ruling party the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) Bhupendra Yadav said holding simultaneous elections will ensure "consistency, continuity and governance." But this would need amendment to the country's Constitution and electoral laws.

Presenting a diagonally opposite argument, the country's former Election Commission chief S.Y. Quraishi said the idea of holding simultaneous elections was very much "against the spirit of the Constitution and federalism."

Citing practical difficulties, he said that suppose simultaneous elections are held but the government loses its majority in the parliament, it will be difficult to hold a new set of elections in all the states.

Referring to the famous example of former premier Atal Bihari Vajpayee heading a government for 13 days only in 1996, he asked:"Why should the states suffer for the electoral decisions taken at the Centre?"

National and local issues are different, and holding simultaneous elections is likely to blur judgment, he added.

Editor: Yamei
Related News
Xinhuanet

Spotlight: India debates over holding simultaneous polls for Union, states

Source: Xinhua 2018-02-04 18:00:10
[Editor: huaxia]

by Pankaj Yadav

NEW DELHI, Feb. 4 (Xinhua) -- Debate has started in Indian political circles as the country goes to the general elections in 2019.

Three days prior to flying to Davos on Jan. 22 to participate in the World Economic Forum, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi in a TV interview strongly advocated the idea of holding simultaneous elections at the Centre and in all the states.

This, he said, will save a lot of money and also let the politicians focus on works for full five years without being disturbed by elections, which have lately become a round-the-year event in India.

On an average, as many as five Indian states go to polls every year. Whenever the states go to polls, it becomes a slugfest between the ruling and the opposition parties. As all resources are diverted to the polls, governance and development works take a back seat during such times.

For the first 20 years since India gained Independence in 1947, elections were held simultaneously for the parliament and all state legislatures. This was so because the polls held in that era gave a decisive verdict to the then ruling party.

The first four simultaneous elections for Centre and states were held in 1951, 1957, 1962 and 1967. But slowly that trend disappeared and frequent mid-term polls were witnessed.

This trend of holding elections at different times for different states, and the Centre, has been there for almost five decades now. More so since the late 1990s, an era which saw many government changes at the Centre and multiple parliamentary elections held over a span of four years. The government headed by former premier Atal Bihari Vajpayee in 1996 lasted only for 13 days.

Hence comes forth this proposal of holding simultaneous elections in both states and at the Centre. The idea gained significance especially after reiteration by Modi on Jan. 19. Though there are valid arguments cited against the idea too.

Supporting the idea per se, Dr Jaswant Singh, a political analyst in Delhi, said that it's a good idea if implemented.

"Just like in the United States and in other countries where federal and provincial elections are held simultaneously, we can also think of adopting the idea," he said.

Toeing the prime minister's line, senior leader of the country's main ruling party the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) Bhupendra Yadav said holding simultaneous elections will ensure "consistency, continuity and governance." But this would need amendment to the country's Constitution and electoral laws.

Presenting a diagonally opposite argument, the country's former Election Commission chief S.Y. Quraishi said the idea of holding simultaneous elections was very much "against the spirit of the Constitution and federalism."

Citing practical difficulties, he said that suppose simultaneous elections are held but the government loses its majority in the parliament, it will be difficult to hold a new set of elections in all the states.

Referring to the famous example of former premier Atal Bihari Vajpayee heading a government for 13 days only in 1996, he asked:"Why should the states suffer for the electoral decisions taken at the Centre?"

National and local issues are different, and holding simultaneous elections is likely to blur judgment, he added.

[Editor: huaxia]
010020070750000000000000011103261369484731
大发彩票 大发app 凤凰彩票app 乐发iv游戏平台 凤凰彩票大厅 乐发彩票 乐发彩票app下载 大发彩票 乐发v官网 乐发lll 乐发lv入口 乐发iv首页 乐发ll登录 凤凰彩票大厅 乐发官网 乐发ii下载入口 乐发ll 乐发v平台 乐发v官网 乐发lll 乐发lv入口 乐发iv首页 乐发ll登录 乐发lv 乐发lll安装 乐发lv 乐发登录入口 乐发iv游戏平台 凤凰彩票登录 网信彩票 彩神 彩神彩票官方网站 彩神彩票官网首页 彩神官方app下载安卓版 凤凰彩票登录 彩神v3 凤凰彩票app下载 彩神官方app下载安卓版 网信快三 一分快3 快三彩票购彩平台 凤凰彩票官方 快3官网 网信彩票 快3app 网信彩票平台 百姓彩票平台 网信平台官网 快3app下载 百姓彩票 每日彩票 快3app 百姓彩票 每日彩票 快3app 百姓彩票平台 幸运5分彩快3 快3彩票app下载 百姓彩票网站网址 大发10分PK10 快3下载 网信彩票平台 网信平台官网 快3彩票官网app 凤凰彩票官方 彩神彩票 大发10分PK10 彩神v3 大发彩票app下载 百姓彩票网站网址 彩神购彩平台 每日彩票 官方正规快三彩票平台 彩神彩票购彩平台 百姓彩票 凤凰彩票购彩平台 凤凰彩票app下载 彩神官方app下载安卓版 网信快三 一分快3 快三彩票购彩平台 凤凰彩票官方 彩神彩票 大发10分PK10 彩神v3 凤凰彩票登录 乐发lv 乐发∨Il 百姓彩票网站网址 乐发彩票 乐发彩票官方网站 乐发lll安装 百姓彩票网站网址 凤凰彩票app下载 大发10分PK10 乐发2 乐发app 凤凰彩票 大发彩票app 乐发登录入口 乐发ll登录 乐发v官网 乐发官网 大发彩票app下载 凤凰彩票购彩平台 彩神彩票 官方正规快三彩票平台 一分快3 百姓彩票网站网址 凤凰彩票app下载 大发10分PK10 乐发2 乐发app 凤凰彩票 大发彩票app 乐发登录入口 乐发ll登录 乐发v官网 乐发官网 大发彩票app下载 凤凰彩票购彩平台 彩神彩票 官方正规快三彩票平台 1分快三平台 百姓彩票平台 凤凰彩票登录 幸运5分彩快3 彩神 乐发彩票 乐发 大发彩票 乐发iv游戏平台 乐发lv 乐发lll 乐发ii下载入口 乐发彩票官方网站 凤凰彩票官方网站 凤凰快3 彩神彩票官网首页 1分快三平台 百姓彩票平台 凤凰彩票登录 幸运5分彩快3 彩神 乐发彩票 乐发 大发彩票 乐发iv游戏平台 乐发lv 凤凰彩票app 乐发app 网信彩票平台 网信彩票平台 乐发iv游戏平台 凤凰彩票app 乐发lv 乐发彩票app下载 凤凰彩票app 网信彩票平台 乐发彩票app下载 乐发lv 乐发app 大发彩票安卓下载 大发彩票安卓下载 大发彩票 乐发彩票app下载 网信彩票平台 乐发iv游戏平台 彩神彩票 乐发彩票中心 极速快3彩票平台 人人快三凤凰 大发彩票app 大发彩票大全 乐发彩票 彩神彩票官方网站 乐发app 酷天堂彩票平台 凤凰彩票app下载 凤凰彩票大厅 凤凰彩票app 极速快3彩票平台 凤凰彩票 凤凰快3 乐发ll官网 乐发彩票中心 正规快三送彩金平台 凤凰彩票官方 乐发ll 乐发 网信彩票 彩神彩票 彩神彩票官方网站 大发彩票app 网信彩票用户 百姓快三 百姓彩票平台 乐发lv 乐发彩票app下载 彩信平台 网信彩票 乐发彩票官方网站 乐发∨Il 人人快三凤凰 凤凰彩票 凤凰快3 乐发ll官网 乐发彩票中心 正规快三送彩金平台 凤凰彩票官方 乐发ll 乐发 网信彩票 彩神彩票 彩神彩票官方网站 人人快三凤凰 乐发彩票 彩神彩票 乐发iv游戏平台 乐发彩票 大发彩票中心 凤凰彩票登录 凤凰彩票app 彩神彩票 大发彩票 乐发ll 大发彩票app 凤凰快3 凤凰彩票 彩神彩票 乐发ll 凤凰彩票 乐发lll 凤凰彩票大厅 网信彩票 彩神彩票 乐发lv 快盈彩票 乐发彩票官方网站 盈彩网投资平台 大发官网 一分时时彩 乐发lv 快3平台 凤凰快3 乐发ll 全民彩票 乐发彩票官方网站 百姓彩票 乐发彩票 大发彩票 极速快3 乐发app 大发官网 乐发lll 快3平台 凤凰快3 乐发ll 全民彩票 乐发彩票官方网站 百姓彩票 乐发彩票 大发彩票 极速快3 乐发app 彩神iv 大发彩票app 大小单双平台 一分pk10 乐发lv 快盈彩票 乐发官网 快彩彩票 百姓彩票 凤凰彩票大厅 网信彩票 乐发彩票中心 网信快3 乐发 彩神xl 三分快3 大发彩票 大发官网 乐发lll 快3平台 凤凰快3 乐发ll 全民彩票 乐发彩票官方网站 百姓彩票 乐发彩票 乐发彩票官方网站 大发彩票 乐发 分分快3 彩神vl 55世纪 55世纪 凤凰快3 乐发彩票 乐发lv welcome凤凰彩票 乐发ll 1分快3 彩神 彩神ll 1分快3官网 1分快3的平台 welcome凤凰彩票 三分快3 彩神x 彩神vl 凤凰彩票 彩神xl 大发彩票 凤凰彩票大厅 乐发官网 乐发ll 乐发lll 乐发lv 大发彩票app 大发彩票 乐发 乐发彩票 乐发彩票中心 凤凰快3 乐发彩票 彩神xl 腾讯快3 大发彩票 彩神xl 大发彩票 乐发彩票 大发彩票app 快3平台 乐发 1分快3 乐发彩票 彩神x 凤凰快3 彩神xl 彩吧助手 大发彩票app 快3平台 大发排列3 彩神iv 彩神vl 乐发IV 彩神x 一分pk10 大发排列3 乐发lv 快3彩票 乐发app下载 三分快3 快三平台助手 乐发彩票ll 彩神iv 乐发lll下载 盈彩网投资平台 乐发Ⅲ 一分pk10 凤凰彩票 乐发Vll 大发官网 乐发ll 大发彩票 乐发1 凤凰快3 彩神vl 乐发lx 百姓彩票 乐发VI 彩神x 乐发IV 极速快3 乐发 凤凰快3 网信快3 乐发lv 快3彩票 乐发app下载 三分快3 快三平台助手 乐发彩票ll 彩神iv 乐发lll下载 盈彩网投资平台 乐发Ⅲ 凤凰彩票大厅 乐发lv 乐发lv 乐发lv 凤凰彩票 大发彩票 大发彩票 凤凰彩票 乐发lv 凤凰彩票 凤凰彩票 乐发lv 乐发ll 凤凰彩票app下载 凤凰彩票 凤凰彩票 乐发lv 乐发ll 凤凰彩票app下载 凤凰彩票 凤凰彩票 乐发lv 彩神x 乐发 乐发ll 极速快3 乐发lv 乐发彩票中心 快3彩票 凤凰彩票大厅 彩神x 凤凰彩票app 分分快3 网信彩票 网盟彩票 凤凰彩票 百姓彩票 乐发 快彩彩票 乐发彩票 快3平台 百姓彩票 大小单双平台 凤凰快3 彩神xl 一分pk10 乐发lv 三分快3 大发彩票 乐发彩票 快3平台 百姓彩票 大小单双平台 凤凰快3 彩神xl 一分pk10 乐发lv 三分快3 大发彩票 极速快3 乐发ll 网信彩票 乐发lv 全民彩票 凤凰彩票app下载 快盈彩票 大发彩票app 大发官网 凤凰彩票 彩神iv 大发彩票 网信快3 凤凰彩票 百姓彩票